Russian News  
China cannot back Russia in Georgia crisis: analysts

by Staff Writers
Beijing (AFP) Aug 29, 2008
China will not endorse Russia in its battle with the West over the Georgia crisis but cannot say so publicly for fear of upsetting Moscow, political analysts say.

Since the Georgia crisis began -- culminating in Moscow recognising the independence of two secessionist regions, South Ossetia and Abkhazia -- China's reaction has been subdued.

It has expressed concern over the issue but has refrained from taking sides in what has become an increasingly strident war of words between Russia and the West.

But analysts said that if push came to shove, China's official stance would not support Russia, whose actions violated Beijing's long-held principles of national sovereignty and territorial integrity.

"The official Chinese position, if it were pushed, would be that this is unacceptable," said Paul Harris, professor of political science at Lingnan University in Hong Kong.

"China doesn't want to give the green light to somebody coming to the side of separatist forces within their troubled regions."

Analysts said that China, with its own regions that want or claim independence -- like Xinjiang or Taiwan -- did not want to make these claims legitimate by supporting Russia's action.

Taiwan in particular was at the centre of China's reluctance as Beijing claims the island for itself, while Taiwan says it is an independent country, though with the recognition of only a few countries.

Moscow has faced fierce condemnation from the West over its recognition of the independence of the two regions.

The UN Security Council is discussing the wording of a resolution on the Georgian conflict, and China normally takes Russia's side in Council matters. But it has been largely silent on the Georgian issue.

Analysts were split on how China might vote if a resolution came to the table, although most agreed it was unlikely to come to that as negotiations would be taking place behind the scenes.

"China will not abstain, China is not going to go for something overturning a sovereign government and a sovereign rule," said Bob Broadfoot, head of the Hong Kong-based Political and Economic Risk Consultancy.

"It's just not going to happen, as China's position on Taiwan would go down the drain."

"If the resolution is focused on the question of sovereignty, China may very well side with the West," said Jean-Pierre Cabestan, professor of political science at Hong Kong Baptist University.

"But China will do its upmost to avoid such a resolution being presented to the Security Council, because it doesn't want to damage its relationship with Russia."

Lingnan University's Harris said that China, which he said has an underlying sympathy with Russia over the break-up of the Soviet Union, would hold back from casting its vote.

"It is always possible that the Western countries will force a vote and if it happens, I think China will abstain," he said.

Cabestan said that China was also concerned about the Georgia crisis because it was worried Russia might exert similar pressure on Central Asian states -- all of which were former Soviet republics like Georgia.

"That's not in China's interest, as it has in the past managed to get some influence in Central Asia, and China and Russia both cooperate and compete in the region for influence."

Ultimately, Broadfoot said, the crisis could push China closer to the West.

"China will try to keep quiet," he said. "But if Russia overplays its hand, they will side with the US."

Community
Email This Article
Comment On This Article

Share This Article With Planet Earth
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit
YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook



Related Links
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com

Walker's World: The price of Putin
Paris (UPI) Aug 27, 2008
The extraordinary European summit to be convened Monday by French President Nicolas Sarkozy is intended to agree on a common policy toward Russia in the wake of its short, sharp war with Georgia. Given the divisions of interest between those who depend on Russian oil and gas and those more concerned with a resurgence of Russian bullying, only optimists think it is likely to succeed.







  • China cannot back Russia in Georgia crisis: analysts
  • Russian Incursion Could Speed NATO Integration As Finland Eyes Membership
  • Russia slams West, looks to China for support
  • Outside View: Playing nice with Russia

  • Iran operating 4,000 nuclear centrifuges: report
  • US House speaker to make landmark Hiroshima visit
  • Iran warns any attack would start 'world war'
  • Analysis: North Korean spies in Seoul

  • Analysis: Revolt in India rebel group ULFA
  • Analysis: India mulls new probe agency
  • Analysis: India eyes fake currency flow

  • Chinese police kill six in Xinjiang clash: reports
  • China warns on rural, urban income gap: report
  • China's tallest tower aims to take Shanghai higher
  • Shanghai to open world's highest sightseeing hall to public

  • Turkmenistan pledges more gas to China: president
  • Gulf oil production halted ahead of Hurricane Gustav
  • US to tap oil reserve if storm batters oil-rich Gulf of Mexico
  • Analysis: Sudan courts U.S. with oil

  • ISS Orbit Adjusted To Dodge Space Junk
  • Computer virus goes into orbit
  • ISS Program Facing Hard Choices
  • US-Russia chill threatens NASA space program

  • Satellite's Data Collection Will Support Warfighter
  • Boeing Awarded E-6B Upgrade Contract
  • Defense Support Program Satellite Decommissioned
  • Raytheon Bids For USAF Command And Control Contract

  • Packing A Punch With The T-72 Part One
  • DRS Awarded Contracts To Provide MSTAR
  • Airmen Employ Laser Joint Direct Attack Munition In Iraq
  • Analysis: Airborne IED gets attention

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement