Russian News  
Russian military's roar is hollow: analysts

by Staff Writers
Moscow (AFP) Feb 14, 2008
Dramatic encounters last weekend between Russian and US warplanes over a US aircraft carrier seemed to underline President Vladimir Putin's boast that Russia is again a world player -- but analysts are less sure.

The Cold War-style incident on Saturday involved Russian TU-95 Bear bombers, US F-18 fighters, and no less than 24 Japanese F-15s, roaring through the skies in the area of the USS Nimitz in the western Pacific near Japan.

A Russian air force official told the Interfax news agency Wednesday that the Russian planes were simply on "routine training" and again denied Tokyo's claim that Japanese airspace was violated, saying "no international norms... were broken."

However, former air force chief Pyotr Deinekin reflected the pride Russians are taking in such long-range air patrols, renewed last year following a long break due to post-Soviet funding shortages.

"An aircraft carrier is harder to find in the open ocean than a needle in the haystack. The crews had to go directly to their target, in this case the Nimitz, to photograph it," he crowed, Interfax reported.

Almost daily, Russian state television provides glowing reports on the prowess of the military.

The armed forces were at the heart of Soviet ideology and the economy but almost collapsed in the 1990s, when heavily out-gunned Chechen rebels devastated the army, aircraft were grounded and ships rotted.

Today, warplanes routinely probe the airspace of northern European NATO countries.

Earlier this month a Russian naval fleet carried out large-scale manoeuvers in the Mediterranean for the first time since the 1991 Soviet break-up. Strategic bombers later fired tactical missiles over the Bay of Biscay off the Spanish and French coasts.

Throw in Putin's aggressive statements on re-targeting Russian nuclear missiles in response to Western military encroachment and the world might seem set for Cold War, Round Two.

Just this Wednesday, Putin told the Ukrainian president, Viktor Yushchenko, that Moscow might in theory aim "our offensive missile systems at Ukraine" if the ex-Soviet republic joins NATO and hosts US anti-missile defences.

But analysts say Moscow's bark is worse than its bite.

Putin warns of a new arms race and promises a military renaissance, but Russia's military budget is less than one twentieth that in the United States and most of its weaponry is relatively outdated.

"Russia is trying to flex its muscles and trying to be a player on the world stage," Bob Ayers, at the Chatham House think-tank in London, told AFP. But "in a military sense they are not a major player now.... It's just PR."

Russian military analyst Alexander Goltz said that both Moscow and Western political circles were responsible for hyping routine military exercises by Russia's forces.

In the West "certain intellectual circles are searching for confirmation of the Russian leadership's militaristic tendencies," he said. "They exaggerate any military activity."

Meanwhile, Russia's propaganda machine also presents "the most run of the mill exercises as some kind of Russian military comeback."

Maria Lipman, analyst at the Moscow Carnegie Centre, said Putin wants to exorcise Russia's "past humiliations," but that the country's main strategic goal is to build an economic powerhouse based on energy exports.

"Russia, under today's leadership at any rate, is not seeking a Cold War confrontation, a real arms race," Lipman said.

"The rhetoric may get very unpleasant and tough, even aggressive, but I don't think this overshadows the main trend that Russia is interested in commercial profit, in economic success."

Community
Email This Article
Comment On This Article

Related Links
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com

China tells US to drop Cold War attitude after 'spy' arrests
Beijing (AFP) Feb 14, 2008
China on Thursday told the United States to drop its "Cold War" attitude and stop accusing Beijing of espionage, after US authorities arrested four people on charges of spying for the Chinese.







  • China tells US to drop Cold War attitude after 'spy' arrests
  • Russian military's roar is hollow: analysts
  • Walker's World: POTUS has a new rival
  • Putin issues warning to Ukraine on NATO

  • All Iranian nuclear questions must be answered: France
  • Russia To Target New Threats As NATO Says It Will Decide Who Joins Alliance
  • Russia Not Happy With Iranian Rocket And Uranium Developments
  • Pakistan tests nuclear-capable missile: army

  • Process On For Establishing Aerospace Command
  • Cisco plans to turn India into global hub, triple workforce
  • India's Biotech Baby Elephant

  • Mao proposed sending 10 million Chinese women to US
  • US Treasury cautions China over sovereign wealth fund
  • World Bank slashes 2008 China growth forecast
  • China, US aluminum giants buy into Rio Tinto

  • Gage Provides Fuels For 2008 SAE Clean Snowmobile Challenge
  • Peabody Energy CEO Calls Clean Coal The Primary Sustainable Choice For Growing Energy Needs
  • Analysis: Big Oil tackles climate change
  • Project Targets Commercial Viability For Enhanced Geothermal Systems

  • Schlegel Completes First Spacewalk
  • Astronauts complete successful spacewalk
  • STS-122 Spacewalkers Complete Second Outing As Mission Extended
  • Columbus Installed In New Home On ISS

  • EADS DS Delivers Army Command And Control Information System To Franco-German Brigade
  • Thompson Files: Electronic war blindness
  • Harris Provides American Forces Network With Broadcast System To Reach One Million Troops
  • Raytheon Wins Air Force Satellite Communications Contract

  • New Radar Tracking And Sensor Fusion System Delivered To US Marines
  • Northrop Grumman Completes Demonstration Of New Synthetic Aperture Radar Capability For F-22
  • Chinese Weaponry In The Early 21st Century Part Four
  • Taiwan assesses damage after China spy ring revealed in US

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement